All articles6 minute read

Why does mom think I’m stealing from her?

You are the one she accuses because you are the one who is there. What caregivers do about it, and what makes it worse.

She cannot find her glasses. Someone must have taken them. You are the someone, because you are the one in the room.

It is worth knowing straight away that this is close to universal, and that it lands hardest on whoever is doing the most. The person who visits twice a year is never the thief. The daughter who moved in is the thief every week.

Knowing that does not make it stop stinging. Here is what people do.

What the accusation is actually doing

Something is missing and there is no memory of moving it. That is frightening, and a thief is a far less frightening answer than a mind that has stopped holding onto where things go.

Caregivers describe the same realization arriving late: she is not accusing you, she is explaining a hole. One put it as "she needs a reason, and I am the only reason standing there."

Do not defend yourself

This is the one everybody learns the hard way. Producing evidence, showing the camera footage, pointing out that the ring was given away in 2011, listing what you have given up to be there. All of it extends the argument and none of it lands.

"I showed her the receipt. She said I printed it." That is the shape of it. The accusation is not an argument you can win, because it was never an argument.

Help her look

Joining the search is the move that comes up most. Not agreeing that it was stolen, just looking. "Let us find it" instead of "nobody took it."

It answers the fear rather than the sentence. Several people say the accusation dissolves partway through the search and is not mentioned again.

One family keeps a short list of the four places things actually turn up, because after a year it was always the same four.

Buy a second one

Glasses, the purse, the remote, a particular blue cardigan. Whatever goes missing most, people buy a duplicate and keep it somewhere only they know.

"Twelve dollars stopped a fight we were having four times a week." It does nothing about the underlying thing. It ends the afternoon.

The purse that is never empty

A common one where money is what goes missing: an old handbag with a small amount of cash and some expired cards in it, kept where she can reach it.

Being able to check and find it there is the point. One caregiver says her mother counts it most days and has never once spent it.

What makes it worse

Reasoning, at length. Involving other relatives to back you up, which reads as everybody ganging up. Moving her things to keep them safe, which creates the exact gap that starts the next accusation.

And taking it personally in front of her. That is the hardest one to avoid and the one people most regret, because the tone is remembered as a feeling long after the words have gone.

When other people believe her

This is the part that gets written about least and hurts most. A sibling who hears it secondhand, a neighbor, occasionally a professional.

Caregivers who have been through it say the same two things: write down what you spend and when, from early on, even when it feels absurd. And get one other person who sees the daily reality, whether that is a doctor, an aide, or a room like this one.

Not because you owe anyone proof. Because being disbelieved on top of everything else is more than most people can carry alone.

One caregiver, three years in: "She told the pharmacist I keep her locked in. He has known me since I was fifteen. He just said mmhmm and kept counting."

That is about as good as this gets, and it is genuinely good enough.

Everything here is what worked for people doing this at home. It is not medical advice, and Kind Soup is not a medical or emergency service. If somebody is in danger, contact your local emergency number.

Written to be sent to somebody who needs it.

Also on Kind Soup

All articles